How is a juvenile proceeding in Florida different from an adult’s prosecution for criminal charges?
Juvenile proceedings in Florida are not technically considered criminal proceedings at all. A juvenile proceeding is a civil matter. Although this distinction exists, the devastating consequences of an arrest and finding of guilt are very similar under Florida law. In a juvenile proceeding, the child can be convicted, and sentenced to imprisonment, residential programs that remove the child from his home, or probation. The child can be ordered to pay restitution and complete community service.
A juvenile does not have all of the same protections that an adult has to defend himself against a false or exaggerated accusation. Most notably, there are no jury trials in juvenile court under Florida law. If the case goes to trial, the juvenile court judge will determine your child’s guilt or innocence. The juvenile does have certain valuable protections, such as the right to a speedy trial. Florida juvenile law requires the prosecutor for the State of Florida to bring the juvenile to trial within 90 (ninety) days of the juvenile's arrest, or the date the petition is filed, whichever occurred first. In certain cases, the attorney may need to waive the right to a speedy trial, however that is an important decision that must be decided carefully as part of an overall strategy.
If you need the advice of an experienced juvenile criminal defense attorney for a case in Hillsborough County, or any of the surrounding counties, including Polk County, Pasco County, Pinellas County, Manatee County, or Sarasota County, call 813-250-0500 to discuss your case with an attorney today.
Back to top
Stages of a Juvenile Case - Arrest Through Sentencing
I. Juvenile Court Referral Process
Once the juvenile has been arrested for a violation of a criminal law the child will be taken to the Juvenile Assessment Center (JAC) where the JAC will determine whether further detention is necessary.
After a child is arrested and detained, the juvenile is taken to a juvenile detention center in the county in which the offense allegedly occurred. During the intake process, the JAC staff will contact the juvenile's parents. A juvenile arrested in Hillsborough County, Florida, can be taken to either of the following Hillsborough County juvenile detention centers in Tampa:
- Hillsborough County Juvenile Assessment Center8605 N Branch Ave Tampa, FL 33604(813) 936-9099
- Hillsborough Regional Juvenile Detention Center East9504 East Columbus Drive, Tampa, FL 33619Phone Number: 813-664-4100 FAX: 813-664-4115
- Hillsborough Regional Juvenile Detention Center, West3948 W. Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd., Tampa, FL 33614
Phone Number: 813-871-7650 FAX: 813-871-4764
A juvenile arrested in Polk County will be taken to the following Polk County juvenile detention center, in Bartow, Florida:
- Polk Regional Juvenile Detention Center
2155 Bob Phillips Road, Bartow, FL 33830Phone Number: 863-534-7090 FAX: 863-534-7024
A juvenile arrested in Pinellas County, may be brought to the following Pinellas County juvenile detention center in Clearwater, Florida:
- Pinellas Regional Juvenile Detention Center5255 140th Avenue North, Clearwater, FL 33760Phone Number: 727-538-7100 FAX: 727-538-7318
A juvenile arrested in Pasco County will be taken to the following Pasco County juvenile detention center in San Antonio, Florida:
- Pasco Regional Juvenile Justice Detention Center28534 State Road 52, San Antonio, FL 33576Phone Number: 352-588-5900 FAX: 352-588-5909
After the juvenile is admitted to the Florida juvenile detention center, the juvenile will be taken before the juvenile court within 24 hours for a detention hearing. An experienced Tampa juvenile criminal defense attorney can represent your child at the detention hearing to provide your child with the best chance of being released while the case is pending.
Florida juvenile detention facilities are designed as a temporary program to house the juvenile prior to the resolution of the juveniles court case. Juvenile detention centers are used on a temporary basis to house juveniles while their cases are pending. If the juvenile is found guilty, the child can be sentenced to a long term residential program or a non-residential program as discussed below.
Back to top
II. Juvenile Detention Hearings in Florida
Within 24 hours of the juvenile being taken to the Juvenile Assessment Center (JAC), the juvenile will be brought before the court for a detention hearing. The juvenile can be represented by a Tampa juvenile criminal defense attorney at the hearing. At the juvenile detention hearing, the court will review the allegations, the juvenile's history, and other circumstances to determine whether the juvenile's detention should be continued, whether the juvenile should be released to his parent or guardian, or whether the juvenile should be placed on home detention. In certain cases, the child is released to his parents before the detention hearing, in those cases the child and his parent must appear at the detention hearing the next morning.
The Florida juvenile court judge can release the child at the detention hearing, or continue the detention for up to 21 days. Hiring an experienced Tampa juvenile defense attorney to appear at the detention hearing can make the difference between the child's detention being continued, or the child being released back to his or her parent.
Back to top
III. Juvenile Intake Process
The Florida Juvenile Probation Officer (JPO) will initiate the intake process by reviewing a copy of the charging report from the officer that made the arrest or the clerk of the court. The JPO then contacts the juvenile and his family to request additional biographical information about the child, his family, school, and activities. A juvenile defense attorney can assist the family in providing this information and presenting all favorable biographical information and mitigating factors to the JPO.
The information gathered during the intake process will be used by the JPO to make a recommendation to the court about how the charges against the juvenile should be resolved. The JPO's report and recommendation will address the type of offense charged, the juvenile's risk to the community, the wishes of the alleged victims, and the needs of the juvenile. The intake report and recommendation is then forwarded to the State Attorney's Office. Having a juvenile defense attorney involved with the intake process can often make a big difference in the way the case is handled by the State Attorney's Office.
Back to top
IV. Juvenile Diversion Programs
An experienced Tampa juvenile criminal defense attorney can fight to have the child placed in the most favorable diversion program. If the JPO recommends a non-judicial intervention program, also called a Florida juvenile diversion program, then this recommendation is reviewed by the Assistant State Attorney assigned to the case. If the State Attorney's Office agrees, then the juvenile and his parents must sign certain documents to take advantage of this program. First, the juvenile and parents must sign a waiver of speedy trial rights and agreement to complete all of the requirements of the diversion program. The diversion program essentially "diverts" the juvenile away from the Florida juvenile courts and through a program run by the State Attorney's Office.
If the juvenile successfully completes the program, then the prosecutor takes no further action to formally prosecute the charges. On the other hand, if the juvenile does not successfully complete the program, then the state attorney's office will file a formal charge in the clerk of court's office, called a petition, against the juvenile. If the child is subsequently "rejected" from the diversion program, it is important to have an experienced juvenile defense attorney represent the child in front of the juvenile court judge.
Back to top
V. Juvenile Court Intervention
If the juvenile does not successfully complete the Florida juvenile diversion program, or if the State Attorney's Office will not agree to offer a diversion program that the juvenile agrees to take, then the State Attorney's Office will file formal charges of the criminal offense, called a petition, with the clerk of court.
In certain cases, an experienced Tampa juvenile attorney can discuss with the client and the parent the pros and cons of entering a juvenile drug court program which exists in certain counties throughout Florida, including Hillsborough County. Juvenile drug court is not appropriate in all cases, and it may not be in the juvenile's best interest if valid defenses to the charges exist, if the charges are not serious enough to warrant drug court, or if the child is innocent of the offense charged.
Hillsborough County has developed a Juvenile Drug Court which was established in 1996. The Hillsborough County Juvenile Drug Court is aimed at yours who have committed drug offenses or have a history of substance abuse issues. The benefit of Juvenile Drug Court is that if the program is completed successfully, the charges will be dismissed, and the child will not be convicted of a delinquent act. The downside of the program is that the juvenile must enter a plea and be placed on probation. A violation of that probation could result in a harsher sentence, which could include the child being removed from the home. The program typically takes 12 months to complete. The juvenile must complete all contractual requirements that are negotiated before agreeing to the program, have a screening assessment, submit to a urine drug test, have a drug and alcohol evaluation, complete any recommended drug or alcohol treatment, stop using drugs or alcohol, and pursue a GED or attend school on a full-time basis.
Back to top
VI. Winning the Juvenile Case at Trial
Preparing a juvenile case for trial is very similar to preparing an adult case for trial. The attorney is allowed to speak to the witnesses involved, including public school resource officers, teachers, administrators, other children, and neighbors who may have knowledge about the case. When a felony offense is alleged, the attorney has the opportunity to take the deposition of the witnesses involved. After a complete investigation of all of the evidence and witnesses that the State intends to introduce at trial, the juvenile defense attorney can also present witnesses or evidence that support the juvenile's side of the event. The juvenile defense attorney can file motions to suppress evidence and/or motion to dismiss the charges. In many cases in which the juvenile has been falsely accused the prosecutor will agree to drop the charges before trial. The judge may dismiss the charges before trial based on a defense motion. In other cases, it may be in the juvenile's best interest to take the case to trial after pursuing all pre-trial motions to resolve the case. If the case proceeds to trial and the child is found not guilty, then the case is over. The juvenile's record will be sealed.
Back to top
VII. Sentences Imposed if Juvenile is Found Guilty at Trial
If the child is found guilty of the offense after entering an admission or being found guilty by the court after a trial, the following types of punishments can be imposed:
- Probation
- Residential Commitment and Aftercare Supervision
- Adult Sanctions
Probation Sentences for Juveniles
The court can order a supervision program called probation after a juvenile has been found guilty of a delinquent act. Probation is a form of supervision that restricts the child's freedom and activities and is ordered instead of committing the child to the custody of the Department of Juvenile Justice.
A probation sentence usually orders the child to complete certain conditions such as community service hours, and paying restitution to the victims to compensate them for financial damages. A condition of probation can also involve submitting to an mental health evaluation and submitting to counseling. Counseling can involve anger management classes and substance abuse counseling. The court can also impose a curfew and day treatment program, which provides additional supervision of juveniles in an educational setting.For certain offenses, the court can order the child to submit a biological sample for DNA testing.
Violation of Juvenile Probation
After a juvenile is placed on probation, a Juvenile Probation Officer (JPO) is assigned. The JPO will supervise the child to determine whether the child is complying with the court ordered special conditions of probation. The court may also order that the parents of guardian of the child report any violations of the court order by the child to the JPO and to the court.
If the juvenile commits a new offense or fails to timely complete the special conditions ordered by the court, the JPO will file a Violation of Probation Petition. If the court finds the violation of probation did occurred, the court may revoke probation and impose an alternative sentence, such as placement in a residential facility run by the Department of Juvenile Justice or any other sentence that could have originally been imposed.
Post Commitment Probation or Conditional Release
After the juvenile is released from a residential program, the juvenile will be supervised as part of post commitment probation or conditional release. Both post commitment probation and conditional release require the juvenile to comply with special conditions that are similar to those imposed in a probation sentence. Violations can result in the juvenile being recommitted into a more restrictive residential program.
Conditional Release supervision violations are governed by administrative hearings conducted by department staff of the Department of Juvenile Justice. The court is not involved in conditional release violations.
On the other hand, violations of post commitment probation are handled by the court in the same manner as violation of probation cases.
Back to top
VIII. Juvenile Charges Sent to Adult Court in Florida
For certain types of felony charges, it is possible for the juvenile's charges to be filed in adult criminal Circuit Court by either Direct File, Waiver or Indictment. Once the case is transferred to adult court, the juvenile can be tried and sentenced to adult sanctions, including prison.
In Florida, any person arrested for a criminal offense who is under the age of 18 is considered a juvenile. However, even juvenile offenses can be transferred to adult court. Any felony offense allegedly committed by a 16 or 17 year old person can be transferred to adult court. Even a 14 or 15 year old child can be charged in adult court for certain offenses such as grand theft auto, robbery, aggravated battery or possession of a weapon on school grounds. Any offenses committed with a firearm under the "10-20-Life" provisions of Florida Law can be transferred to adult court. If the State Attorney's Office files the charges in adult court, then the juvenile is transferred to the county jail to a pod with other juveniles facing similar charges. Once the case is transferred to adult court, the juvenile is entitled to a bond hearing under the same provisions as an adult with similar charges.
After a plea or finding of guilt, the Department of Corrections will normally file a report that makes certain recommendations to the Court regarding the juvenile's charges. It is possible for a juvenile found guilty in adult court to be sent back to the Department of Juvenile Justice for the imposition of juvenile programs and sanctions.
Back to top
Terms Used in Juvenile Courts in Florida
Adjudication- finding by the Juvenile Court that a child accused of a delinquent act committed the act either after a plea or trial.
Disposition- services order or sanctions imposed by the juvenile judge (or agreed to in a diversion program) for the purpose of addressing juvenile’s illegal act and holding child accountable for problematic behavior.
Detention- status of a juvenile being secured in a juvenile facility under order of the court on a temporary basis while awaiting a juvenile court hearing.
Petition- the document that formally brings charges against the child in juvenile court (analogous to the term “indictment” in adult court).
Secure Placement- status of a juvenile being held in a secure facility under court order for the purpose of complying with the terms of a disposition order (analogous to the term “incarceration” in adult court).
Back to top
Conclusion
Juvenile court is very different from adult court. Hire an experienced Florida juvenile attorney to represent your child in Tampa, Bartow, St. Petersburg, Clearwater, New Port Richey or Dade City. Contact Tampa juvenile court attorney Leslie Sammis to discuss your child's case by calling 813-250-0500. The Sammis Law Firm represents juveniles charged with crimes in Tampa, Hillsborough County, Pinellas County, Polk County, Pasco County, Manatee County, Sarasota County and the surrounding areas.
Back to top